Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Review of CMS Mathematics Competition Resources

 The Canadian Mathematical Society provides mathematics competitions, preparation resources, and enrichment opportunities. The Canadian Open Mathematics Challenge offers a route towards the Canadian Mathematical Olympiad and further international opportunities. After exploring the competition materials, I think the progression of difficulty within the competition system is sensible and the selection structure is reasonable. 

My main concern is that the gap between regular high school mathematics and advanced competition mathematics might be too wide. This gap involves much more than encountering unfamiliar topics. It also involves the breadth and depth of mathematical understanding, especially the ability to construct proofs. Although B.C.’s curriculum includes reasoning and proof, I question whether students receive enough sustained practice to make this transition. Even a student who performs very well by the standards of our school system may still struggle to understand how to develop a mathematical argument.

My own schooling in China shapes this concern. Proof and demanding problems in geometry and algebra were substantial parts of my mathematics education. This provided some of the habits of thinking needed to approach competition problems, even though competitions required additional preparation. I worry that students with similar potential may have a much larger gap to cross when their regular classes provide less experience with this kind of reasoning.

I would therefore like to see more accessible advanced courses and sustained enrichment within schools, connecting regular mathematics with competition preparation. CMS already offers resources and math camps that could support this work. As a teacher, I could use selected problems to introduce increasingly demanding reasoning and help interested students develop their proof-writing skills over time. Such opportunities could also help teachers recognize potential in students who have had little previous exposure to competitions. 

Another concern is whether there are enough incentives for students and schools to invest in advanced mathematics. I do not mean that rewards are entirely absent. Rather, my impression is that meaningful rewards are too limited, and the level of achievement needed to obtain them is too high. Students need reasons to begin and continue, not only recognition once they have reached the top. If a substantial investment of time and effort offers little prospect of recognition or educational opportunity, many capable students may never try. Schools may also be less willing to devote resources to developing their mathematical talent. More attainable intermediate rewards could help sustain participation before students reach an elite level.

This issue is closely connected to university admissions and the different achievements that society chooses to recognize. I question whether a student must reach a much more exceptional level in mathematics competitions to gain an admissions advantage comparable to that available through athletics or other extracurricular achievements. Addressing this would require coordination among universities, schools, and governments, whose priorities may differ. I understand that universities consider many qualities beyond mathematical ability, and I would not assume that mathematics should automatically take priority. Nevertheless, these choices influence which talents students are encouraged to develop. An environment that offers limited incentives for advanced mathematics may make it harder to identify and nurture mathematical talent. This is not necessarily a wrong choice, but it is a social trade-off whose consequences deserve attention.

International competitions necessarily demand a high standard. My suggestion is to give more students a realistic opportunity to reach it. The value would extend beyond medals: developing mathematical talent can support future work in mathematics, science, and technology. How extensively public education should invest in this remains a policy decision, but I think the connection between ordinary classrooms and advanced mathematical opportunities deserves greater attention.

Saturday, October 24, 2026

Pro-D Day Reflection

For Pro-D Day, I attended the Educator Open House at the Beaty Biodiversity Museum. The museum is a beautiful place, with an impressive blue whale skeleton and collections of animals, plants, and fossils. These displays show the beauty and diversity of the natural world.

I am still thinking about how these experiences could connect with mathematics teaching. Perhaps learning can begin with observing patterns, comparing sizes, and asking questions about what we see. These could provide opportunities for students to connect mathematical ideas with the world around them.

Perhaps my difficulty in recognizing these connections comes from my engineering background and way of thinking. I may focus too much on the engineering applications of mathematics. I usually find mathematics most meaningful when it helps solve practical problems or explore the deepest questions about the universe. However, many students may learn mathematics to understand the world better without needing to study it at an advanced level. I still find it challenging to understand what mathematics can offer beyond the purposes I am familiar with. This is something I need to continue exploring so that I can better understand the needs of different students.

Self-Reflection on Group Microteaching

 
















For our group microteaching, we introduced the fundamental counting principle and permutations through a menu problem and a flag communication problem. Overall, I think our group worked well together. Several classmates appreciated the examples, humour, and teamwork. I think beginning with concrete situations helped students understand what we were counting before introducing the mathematical notation.

However, I agree with the feedback that we needed more time for students to practice and for a clearer conclusion. I also felt that we did not have enough time towards the end. We probably planned too much content for a fifteen-minute lesson. This shows that we still need more experience in lesson planning, especially in estimating how much we can reasonably cover. Having enough time to explain something does not necessarily mean that students have enough time to understand and use it.

If I teach this lesson again, I would simplify the content and leave more time for practice and a final summary. I also need to make my demonstration clearer and explain how it connects with the main topic. For example, I could use actual coloured cards to show why changing the order creates a different signal, and then let students try a similar problem themselves. In future lesson planning, I should pay more attention to the time students need to think, discuss, and practice, as well as the time I need to explain.

Wednesday, October 21, 2026

Group Microteaching Lesson Plan

 

Group Microteaching Lesson Plan

Course: Foundations of Mathematics 12
Topic: Introduction to Permutations
Length: 15 minutes
Group members: Eric, Henry, Brandon, and Jacklyn

Materials:

  • One worksheet for each pair

  • Four coloured cards or paper flags per pair: red, blue, green, yellow

  • Whiteboard and markers

  • Timer

Space and grouping:

  • Students sit in pairs. Each pair receives a worksheet and four coloured cards.

Learning objectives:

By the end of the lesson, students will be able to:

  • use the fundamental counting principle to count outcomes with two independent choices;

  • identify when order matters;

  • understand a permutation as an ordered arrangement;

  • connect 4! or 4P4 to a concrete situation.

BC Curriculum connection:

  • Foundations of Mathematics 12: combinatorics, including permutations, combinations, pathways, and Pascal’s Triangle.

Differentiation/inclusion:

  • Students can draw a table or tree diagram before using multiplication.

  • Students can manipulate the coloured cards physically in the flag problem.

  • Key vocabulary is visible: choice, order, arrangement, permutation.

  • Students who finish early can explain why a different flag order creates a different message.

Safety:

  • No physical hazards. Students remain seated; the castle scenario is clearly fictional.

Intro — 0:00–1:00

Eric introduces the lesson:

“Today we will begin with a simple menu problem. First, we will count choices. Then we will look at a different situation where the order of those choices matters.”

Other teachers will distribute worksheets

Body part 1: Fundamental Counting Principle - 1:00–5:00

Worksheet question

Eric has recently learned four ways to cook meat:

  • grilling

  • roasting

  • braising

  • stir-frying

His refrigerator contains chicken, lamb, and beef. Eric wants to invite Henry for dinner and make a menu so Henry can choose a dish.

If each dish uses one type of meat and one cooking method, what is the maximum number of different dishes Eric can put on the menu?

Students first work independently, then compare with a partner.

Expected reasoning

There are:


3 choices of meat4 choices of cooking method

Therefore:


34=12

different dishes.

Teacher explanation

Henry records examples:

  • grilled chicken

  • roasted chicken

  • braised chicken

  • stir-fried chicken

Then asks:

“For each kind of meat, how many cooking methods are possible?”

Conclude:

“When we make one choice and then another choice, we can multiply the number of possibilities.”

Make clear:

“This is the fundamental counting principle. It is not yet a permutation, but it will help us count permutations.”

Body part 2: Flag Communication — 5:00–9:00

Worksheet question

You and your best friend are trapped in two castles one kilometre apart, but you can see each other.

You agree to communicate with four flags: red, blue, green, and yellow.

To represent one letter, you will wave all four flags one at a time, using each colour exactly once.

For example, R-B-G-Y represents one letter.

What is the maximum number of different letters that you can represent?

Students arrange their coloured cards and work with a partner.

Teacher prompts

Brandon asks:

  • “How many choices are there for the first flag?”

  • “After choosing the first flag, how many colours remain?”

  • “Is R-B-G-Y the same letter as R-B-Y-G?”

  • “Why?”

Expected reasoning


4321=24

There are 24 different possible signals.

This is different from the menu problem because the order of the flags matters. R-B-G-Y and R-B-Y-G use the same four colours, but they communicate different letters.

Body part 3: Introducing Permutations — 9:00–12:30

Jacklyn introduces the abstract concept:

“A permutation is an arrangement of objects in which order matters.”

Write:


4!=4321=24

Then connect it to the flag problem:

“In our flag problem, we are arranging four different colours. The first colour matters, the second colour matters, and so on. Therefore, this is a permutation.”

Then briefly distinguish the examples:

Example


What are we counting?


Does order matter?

Eric’s menu

A meat choice and a cooking-method choice

No

Flag communication

An ordered arrangement of four colours

Yes

Finish with:

“The multiplication principle helps us count both problems. A permutation is a special counting situation where the order of the choices creates different outcomes.”

Body part 4: Open-ended Thinking Question - 12:30–14:00

Ask students to discuss with their partner:

“In reality, you only have two hands. What could be a better way to communicate with your friend using flags?”

Possible ideas:

  • use left and right hands differently;

  • use flag position or movement as part of the code;

  • reuse colours in a longer signal;

  • create a beginning/end signal;

  • use two flags at once, then another two flags.

Teachers should not insist on one correct answer. The point is for students to notice that changing the communication rules changes the mathematics used to count possible messages.

End — 14:00–15:00

Quick formative assessment

Students answer:

You have five different flags. You make a signal by waving three different flags one at a time. How many possible signals are there?

Expected answer:


543=60

Ask one student to explain why this is a permutation.


Monday, October 19, 2026

Self-Reflection on Individual Micro-Teaching

 For my individual micro-teaching, I introduced some formatting rules in ancient Chinese official writing. My purpose was not to judge whether this system was good or bad. I only wanted to show that writing formats could reflect hierarchy in a very direct way. For example, the size and position of certain characters could show respect for the emperor, his ancestors, or heaven.

Overall, I think the lesson was successful in terms of content, preparation, timing, and teacher presence. My peers said that the topic was interesting and that the visual examples helped them understand how the different sizes and positions of characters represented hierarchy. I was also happy that I had enough time to explain the more technical parts of the examples instead of moving through them too quickly.

However, the main weakness was that the lesson was still more like a lecture than an interactive activity. I asked some questions, but students did not have enough opportunity to analyze the examples by themselves. I agree with the feedback that more scaffolding and hands-on activities would make the lesson more engaging. If I teach this topic again, I would give students two or three short examples of official writing and ask them to identify which characters are larger, smaller, or raised, and then guess what this formatting means before I explain it.

I also think my demonstration could be clearer and my script could be more polished. In a ten-minute lesson, I need to choose fewer points and make the main idea more obvious. This experience reminded me that interesting content alone is not enough. Students need a clear task that helps them participate and construct the meaning by themselves.








Thursday, October 15, 2026

Response to Malihe Manzouri’s Workshop (posted on my 450 blog before by mistake)

 I was impressed by the activity where we had to imagine that our own child had moved to Tehran and we needed to help the child study and adapt there. It was very enlightening because it showed that language is only one part of the problem. Even if some words can be translated, it is still difficult to understand how the school system works, what different options mean, and whether the information is reliable. This made me think about immigrant families coming to Canada. As a future teacher, I should not assume that families already understand our school routines, course choices, or assessment expectations.

I also think the connection with mathematics teaching is very important. A student from another country may understand the mathematics, but may use different notation, answer formats, or ways of showing their thinking. Therefore, teachers should not immediately conclude that a student does not understand. We need to find out what the student already knows and understand the educational background they bring to the classroom.

Wednesday, October 14, 2026

Microlesson

Individual Non-Curricular Microteaching Lesson Plan

Teacher: Henry Zhao
Topic: Ancient Chinese “APA Style”: Formatting Hierarchy in a Qing Memorial
Time: 10 minutes
Learners: Group 3 peers
Space: Assigned indoor class area

Before the lesson

Learning objectives

By the end of the lesson, learners will be able to:

  1. Explain the basic meaning of tai tou (抬头) in Qing official documents.
  2. Identify how word size, raised spaces, and blank spaces expressed hierarchy.
  3. Recognize that document formatting can express social values, not only organize information.

Materials

  • Slide deck and screen
  • Image of Nian Gengyao’s memorial
  • Japanese ojigi hanko image
  • Optional printed copy of the memorial as a backup

Scope and sequence

This is a short historical introduction, not a full lesson on Chinese history or Qing politics. The focus is on one clear idea: document format made hierarchy visible.

Differentiation and inclusion

Chinese terms will be shown with English translations. Learners do not need to read classical Chinese. Questions will allow people to participate through observation and discussion rather than prior historical knowledge.

Safety and space

Keep bags, cables, and chairs out of the walkway. Since this is a short indoor lesson, there are no special physical hazards.

Beginning — 0:00–0:45

Hook

Show the title slide and ask:

Can formatting show hierarchy, even before we read the words?

Briefly introduce the idea of an ancient Chinese “APA style.”

Middle — 0:45–8:45

TimeTeacher doesLearners doWhy
0:45–2:30Explains that ritual was an important supplement to law in ancient China.Listen and connect the idea to conflict and authority.Provides historical context.
2:30–3:45Shows the Japanese ojigi hanko example.Observe how stamps appear to “bow.”Gives a familiar visual example of visible hierarchy.
3:45–5:00Introduces Nian Gengyao’s 1724 Qing memorial.Look at the document as a visual object.Shifts attention from content to format.
5:00–8:30Explains small 臣/奴才; two raised spaces; 君臣 and 贺; then three raised spaces for 圣祖 and 上苍.Follow the labels and answer questions.Helps learners read hierarchy directly on the page.
8:30–8:45Asks: “Which words are placed highest?”Answer: 圣祖 and 上苍.Quick formative assessment.

End — 8:45–10:00

Conclusion

Modern APA style tells us how to organize and cite information. This Qing format showed hierarchy through empty space, word size, and position.

I do not want to say this system was better or worse. I only want to share an interesting historical fact.

Assessment

  • Teacher observation during questions
  • Peer assessment slip provided by Susan
  • Self-reflection after the microteaching

Connection to upcoming work

This lesson can lead to a broader discussion of how modern formats, titles, language, and institutional rules may also communicate values and hierarchy.









 

Review of CMS Mathematics Competition Resources

 The Canadian Mathematical Society provides mathematics competitions, preparation resources, and enrichment opportunities. The Canadian Open...